Lila, Polly, and Shani deliver a box containing Eva’s special tiara, but when Eva opens the box, the tiara is missing! Nic steps in as detective, using all the skills he learned from mystery podcasts to interrogate each potential tiara-loser (Polly, Shani, and Lila). As he does, we see reenactments of each girl’s day, from Lila’s fashion fiasco to Polly’s journey of snowball near misses. Nic’s quest to find the culprit will take an unexpected turn as he digs into the events.